An Irish Christmas dinner can have the turkey, the ham and the spiced beef, but the moment everyone remembers is the lights going down and the pudding arriving in blue flame. The Irish Times columnist Frank McNally put the rule in one line: “no pudding is complete until it has been set on fire.” Here is what he said about it, why a flame so often refuses to light, and how to flame a pudding with Irish whiskey and no drama.

“No pudding is complete until it has been set on fire”
In his Irish Times piece on the Irish Christmas, published on Christmas Eve 2014, McNally wrote that “even in these weight-conscious times no traditional Christmas is complete without plum pudding”. Then came the second half of the sentence, the one people repeat: no pudding is complete until it has been set on fire.
So the flame is not a restaurant trick. In his account it is part of what makes the pudding a Christmas pudding at all.
Whiskey first, or brandy
McNally calls the classic fuel “whiskey, Irish preferably, or brandy”. That suits us. If you made your pudding with a splash of Irish whiskey, as in our classic Irish Christmas pudding, a little more whiskey over the top at the end is the natural finish. If brandy is what the house has, use that. For the cream, our homemade brandy butter is the other old companion.
Why the flame so often fails
McNally also admits that “getting these to make a convincing blaze on a pudding is not as easy as it sounds”. The commonest reason is that people pour the spirit straight over the pudding and then hold a match to it. A writer at The Gentleman’s Journal calls that one of the main mistakes: pour the brandy on before lighting, and it is “nigh on impossible to catch”.
The fix is to heat the spirit first and light it before it touches the pudding. The same piece says to use three or four tablespoons in a long-handled metal ladle, heated over a gas flame until hot, and to light it while it is still in the ladle. Then pour it over the pudding at once and carry it carefully to the table. It also asks for a serving plate with a little depth and a good rim around the pudding, to catch the spirit.
And the vodka?
McNally recalls that the cook Nigella Lawson once suggested vodka instead of whiskey or brandy. His verdict was a joke that has stuck with us: if you have no respect for tradition, you might as well use petrol. We would stay with whiskey.
Cook the Irish classics at home ☘️
Get our free Irish recipes, with the traditional method for each dish.
How to serve a flaming Irish whiskey Christmas pudding (serves 8)

This is the serving method, not a new pudding. Use your own pudding or a bought one, and heat it the way the recipe or the pack says (our own pudding is steamed again for 2 hours on the day). Do the flaming with the lights dimmed and everyone told to stand back. Keep sleeves, tea towels and paper decorations well away from the flame.
Ingredients
- 1 hot, cooked Irish Christmas pudding (about 900 g)
- 4 tablespoons Irish whiskey, for flaming
- 250 ml double cream
- 1 tablespoon icing sugar
- 1 tablespoon Irish whiskey, for the cream
Method
- Whip the cream with the icing sugar and 1 tablespoon of whiskey until it just holds soft peaks. Chill.
- Turn the hot pudding out onto a warm serving plate that has a rim, so the spirit is caught.
- Pour 4 tablespoons of whiskey into a long-handled metal ladle and heat it over a gas flame until it is hot. If you have no gas hob, heat it in a small saucepan without boiling it, then pour it into the ladle.
- Light the hot whiskey in the ladle with a long match or by tilting the ladle to the gas flame, and pour it at once over the pudding. Point the ladle away from you as you pour.
- Carry the pudding to the table while the flame is still alight. When it dies down, cut the pudding and serve with the whiskey cream and brandy butter.
For the pudding itself, make our classic Irish Christmas pudding and see the rest of the table in Irish Christmas food: pudding, cake, turkey and brandy butter. If you are cooking the main course too, we have the Christmas goose that came before turkey.
Do you light yours with whiskey or brandy?
Sources
- Frank McNally’s Irish Christmas, The Irish Times, 24 December 2014
- How to light a Christmas pudding, The Gentleman’s Journal
Checked November 2026.
☘️ Join 64,000+ Ireland Lovers
Every Friday, get Ireland’s hidden gems, local secrets, and travel inspiration — the kind you won’t find in any guidebook.
Already subscribed? Download your free Ireland guide (PDF)
Free forever · One email per week · Unsubscribe anytime
Secure Your Dream Irish Experience Before It’s Gone!
Planning a trip to Ireland? Don’t let sold-out tours or packed attractions spoil your journey. Iconic experiences like visiting the Cliffs of Moher, exploring the Rock of Cashel, or enjoying a guided walk through Ireland’s ancient past often sell out quickly—especially during peak travel seasons.

Booking in advance guarantees your place and ensures you can fully immerse yourself in the rich culture and breathtaking scenery without stress or disappointment. You’ll also free up time to explore Ireland’s hidden gems and savour those authentic moments that make your trip truly special.
Make the most of your journey—start planning today and secure those must-do experiences before they’re gone!




